ISAA Blog

Tempo Runs vs Intervals: What Each Running Workout Does

Threshold, VO2max intervals, repetitions: what each speed workout builds, what pace to run it at and how many to do per week, per Daniels and the research.

September 28, 20268 min read

You've probably heard it at your running club or read it on a forum: "do intervals to get faster". Fine. But which ones? Tempo, VO2max intervals, 30/30s, all-out 400s? Each workout does something different. Running fast isn't enough. You have to run fast at the right pace, for the right duration.

The good news is that this ground is well mapped. Jack Daniels sorted training paces into five families, and several studies have measured what the best known formats actually do. In this article, you'll see what each type of workout is for, what pace to run it at, and how to fit it into your week without burning out.

Why run at different paces?

Because each pace works a different system. Running slow builds your aerobic base. Running at threshold teaches you to hold a hard pace for a long time. Running near your VO2max makes the engine bigger. Running very fast improves your stride.

Jack Daniels, in Daniels' Running Formula (Human Kinetics, 3rd edition, 2014), gave each pace a letter and a job. These paces are calculated from your VDOT, an index derived from a recent race time.

What are Jack Daniels' 5 training paces?

Here are the five paces, with the intensity ranges Daniels assigns to them (Coach Ray summary, 2023), and the values for a VDOT 40 runner, meaning a 10K in about 50 minutes:

  1. E (Easy): 59 to 74% of VO2max. Aerobic base, injury resistance. For VDOT 40: 5:55 to 6:38/km.
  2. M (Marathon): 75 to 84% of VO2max. Your marathon pace. For VDOT 40: about 5:27/km.
  3. T (Threshold): 83 to 88% of VO2max. Endurance at a hard, sustained pace. For VDOT 40: 5:06/km.
  4. I (Interval): 95 to 100% of VO2max. Aerobic power. For VDOT 40: about 4:40/km, or 1:52 per 400 m.
  5. R (Repetition): faster than VO2max. Speed and running economy. For VDOT 40: 1:46 to 1:48 per 400 m, or about 4:25 to 4:30/km.

The VDOT 40 paces come from Daniels' tables as reproduced by the Traincalc calculator and the Running Calculator, which apply his equations. We cover easy pace in detail in our article on slow running and Zone 2. Here, we focus on the three hard paces: T, I and R.

What is threshold pace in running?

Threshold pace is roughly what you could hold for 50 to 60 minutes in a race. That's Daniels' own definition (VDOT O2, 2025). Physiologically, it sits around 83 to 88% of VO2max.

What it builds: your ability to run fast for a long time without fatigue blowing up. It's the pace that most directly drives your 10K and half marathon times. It should feel "hard but controlled". You can say three words, not a sentence.

The threshold workout (T)

Daniels offers two formats.

The steady tempo run. In his view, the ideal tempo run is a steady 20 minutes at threshold pace (VDOT O2, 2025).

Cruise intervals. Reps of several minutes at threshold pace, with very short recoveries. Daniels' example: 4 × 1 mile (1.6 km) at T pace, 1 minute recovery (same source). The short recovery is the point: it lets you breathe without letting the effort drop.

The cap: no more than 10% of your weekly volume at T pace in a single session (same source).

Real example, VDOT 40, 40 km per week. 10% of 40 km is 4 km. So:

  1. 15 minutes of easy running.
  2. 4 × 1 km at 5:06, 1 minute jog recovery.
  3. 10 minutes of easy running.

Or, as a steady run: 20 minutes at 5:06/km, about 3.9 km. You stay under the cap either way.

The classic trap: running threshold too fast. If you finish the last rep wiped out, you were above it.

How to improve your VO2max (and your MAS)

In France, runners talk about "VMA" (vitesse maximale aérobie), or maximal aerobic speed (MAS): the speed at which you reach your maximal oxygen uptake, also called vVO2max. To raise it, you need to spend time at or near VO2max. Three formats make a strong case.

Daniels' intervals (I)

I pace sits at 95 to 100% of VO2max, a pace you could hold for about 10 to 15 minutes in a race (VDOT O2, 2013).

Daniels' rules:

  1. Reps of 3 to 5 minutes. It takes up to two minutes to reach your VO2max, so shorter reps spend little time there (VDOT O2, 2025).
  2. A very easy jog recovery, equal to or slightly shorter than the rep (same source).
  3. Volume capped at the smaller of two numbers: 8% of weekly volume, or 10 km (VDOT O2, 2013).

And above all: shorter reps are not run faster. The goal is to hit VO2max, not to work on speed (same source).

Real example, VDOT 40, 40 km per week. 8% of 40 km is 3.2 km. So:

  1. 15 to 20 minutes of easy running, plus a few strides.
  2. 4 × 800 m in 3:44 (4:40/km pace), 3 minutes jog recovery.
  3. 10 minutes of easy running.

Billat's 30/30s

Véronique Billat reviewed interval training, its history and its scientific basis (Billat, 2001, Sports Medicine). The 30/30 is one of the formats she measured: 30 seconds at 100% of MAS, 30 seconds at 50% of MAS, alternating.

In her 2000 study, eight distance runners managed an average of 19 reps of 30/30. They spent 7 min 51 s at VO2max, versus 2 min 42 s for a very hard continuous run just below MAS (Billat et al., 2000, European Journal of Applied Physiology). The authors note this says nothing yet about long term effects.

The practical upside: you can do 30/30s without a track.

Real example. 20 minutes of warm-up, then 2 sets of 8 × 30/30, 3 minutes of jogging between sets. If you're new to the format, start with a single set of 8 to 10.

Helgerud's 4 × 4 minutes

Helgerud and colleagues split 40 moderately trained men into four groups doing the same total work, 3 times a week for 8 weeks (Helgerud et al., 2007, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise).

The 4 × 4 minutes at 90 to 95% of max heart rate group, with 3 minutes of active recovery at 70%, gained 7.2% in VO2max. The groups doing slow continuous running (70% of max heart rate) or threshold running (85% of max heart rate) improved clearly less. The authors' conclusion: for the same work, high intensity intervals improve VO2max more.

Real example. 15 minutes of easy running, then 4 × 4 minutes at 90 to 95% of your max heart rate, 3 minutes of jogging between each. It's very close to a Daniels I session, guided by heart rate instead of pace.

What are repetition workouts (R) for?

R pace is faster than VO2max pace. The goal is no longer the engine, it's speed and running economy: learning to run fast, relaxed, with an efficient stride.

Daniels' rules (Coach Ray summary, 2023):

  1. Reps of 2 minutes max.
  2. A long recovery, 2 to 3 times the rep duration. You need to start each one fresh, otherwise your form suffers.
  3. No more than 5% of weekly volume in the session.

The R workout

Real example, VDOT 40, 40 km per week. 5% of 40 km is 2 km. So:

  1. 15 to 20 minutes of easy running.
  2. 8 × 200 m in 53 to 54 seconds, 200 m walk or jog recovery.
  3. 10 minutes of easy running.

It's not a sprint. If you're grimacing, you're going too fast.

How many speed workouts per week?

For most runners: one to two hard sessions a week, no more.

Seiler compiled the training of high level endurance athletes. He observes that about 80% of sessions are done at low intensity and 20% include intensity, such as intervals around 90% of VO2max (Seiler, 2010, International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance). He adds that there's no evidence that going harder brings long term gains in athletes who are already trained.

Applied to you: with 4 runs a week, 20% of sessions is less than one. With 5 or 6 runs, it's one, sometimes two. Going from the study to your week is a rule of thumb, not a number proven for amateur runners. But the direction is clear: the foundation is easy running.

If you're stuck despite plenty of intervals, our article on the running plateau can help you find the problem.

How to schedule hard workouts in your week

Here we leave science and enter coaching convention. Almost everyone shares it, but no study has settled it.

  1. Never two hard sessions back to back. Put at least one easy day or rest day between two quality sessions.
  2. The long run counts as a demanding session. Avoid putting it the day after intervals.
  3. Do your most important session when you're freshest. Often early in the week, after a rest day.

An example 4 run week: Tuesday threshold, Thursday easy run, Saturday easy run, Sunday long run. With 5 runs, you can add an I or R session on Thursday and keep the rest easy.

Do you really need to warm up before intervals?

Yes. Jumping cold into a rep at I pace means asking your body for a maximal effort without preparing it.

The most common format is coaching convention: 15 to 20 minutes of easy running, then 3 or 4 progressive strides of 80 to 100 m. In Billat's 2000 study, runners warmed up for 15 minutes at 50% of their MAS before the tests (Billat et al., 2000).

After the session, a 10 minute cooldown at a very easy jog. That's convention too: it doesn't make the workout more effective, but it helps you come down gently instead of stopping dead.

Summary

Every workout has a job. Threshold (T), at what you could hold for about an hour in a race, lets you run fast for longer: 20 minutes steady or reps with 1 minute recovery, 10% of weekly volume max. Intervals (I), at 95 to 100% of VO2max, make the engine bigger: 3 to 5 minutes per rep, 8% of volume or 10 km max. Billat's 30/30s and Helgerud's 4 × 4 minutes target the same thing. Repetitions (R) work speed and stride, 5% of volume max.

For most runners, one to two hard sessions a week is enough, never on consecutive days, always with a warm-up. Everything else is run easy. That easy running is what lets you nail the hard stuff.

AI running coach

Ready to run with a coach who gets you?

ISAA analyzes your data and coaches you at your own pace, without judgment.

Free · No commitment